Abstract
Drawing on social constructivist approaches to interpreting the generation of knowledge, particularly Stirling’s (Local Environ 4(2):111–135, 1999) schema of incomplete knowledge, this paper looks critically at climate-crop modelling, a research discipline of growing importance within African agricultural adaptation policy. A combination of interviews with climate and crop modellers, a meta-analysis survey of crop modelling conducted as part of the CGIAR’s Climate Change Agriculture and Food Security (CCAFS) programme in 2010, and peer-reviewed crop and climate modelling literature are analysed. Using case studies from across the crop model production chain as illustrations it is argued that, whilst increases in investment and growth of the modelling endeavour are undoubtedly improving observational data and reducing ignorance, the future of agriculture remains uncertain and ambiguous. The expansion of methodological options, assumptions about system dynamics, and divergence in model outcomes is increasing the space and need for more deliberative approaches to modelling and policy making. Participatory and deliberative approaches to science-policy are advanced in response. The discussion highlights the problem that, uncertainty and ambiguity become hidden within the growing complexity of conventional climate and crop modelling science, as such, achieving the transparency and accessibility required to democratise climate impact assessments represents a significant challenge. Suggestions are made about how these challenges might be responded to within the climate-crop modelling community.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Based on the National Research Council’s model of democratic policy making (Stern and Fineberg 1996)
See Ferretti and Pavone (2009) for two recent case studies of this model of risk governance
Web of Knowledge and Science Direct;
Search in ‘title and abstract’ (SD) or ‘topic’ (WoK): ((climate OR precipitation OR temperature OR crop OR yield OR productivity OR agricult* OR maize) AND (process OR trend OR projection OR forecast)) AND model AND (Kenya OR “East* Africa”) AND (uncertain* OR assum* OR unknown)
Screening criteria: Specific focus on Kenya of East Africa; Refers to projections of climate or maize crop models; Published since 1992; Identifies sources of uncertainty in projections
A description of the methodology and results of this survey can be found at http://ccafs.cgiar.org/news/decision-support/crop-modelling-climate-change-and-food-security
References
Anselme B, Bousquet F et al (2010) Modelling of spatial dynamics and biodiversity conservation on Lure mountain (France). Environ Model Softw 25(11):1385–1398
Barnett TP, Pierce DW, et al (2001) Detection of Anthropogenic Climate Change in the World’s Oceans. Science, 292(5515):270–274
Brázdil R, Pfister C, et al (2005) Historical climatology in Europe—State of the art. Climate Change, 70:363–430
Bulkeley H (2001) Governing climate change: the politics of risk society? Trans Inst Br Geogr 26(4):430–447
Burgess J, Stirling A et al (2007) Deliberative mapping: a novel analytic-deliberative methodology to support contested science-policy decisions. Public Underst Sci 16(3):299–322
Challinor A (2010) Regional-scale yield simulations using crop and climate models: assessing uncertainties, sensitivity to temperature and adaptation options. American Geophysical Union, Fall Meeting, Abstract No. GC34A-06
Challinor AJ, Ewert F et al (2009) Crops and climate change: progress, trends, and challenges in simulating impacts and informing adaptation. J Exp Bot 60(10):2775–2789
Challinor AJ, Simelton ES et al (2010) Increased crop failure due to climate change: assessing adaptation options using models and socio-economic data for wheat in China. Environ Res Lett 5:034012
Conway D, Hanson C et al (2007) GCM simulations of the Indian Ocean dipole influence on East African rainfall: present and future. Geophys Res Lett 34(3), L03705
De Marchi B (2003) Public participation and risk governance. Sci Public Policy 30:171–176
Deressa TT, Hassan RM, et al. (2009) Determinants of farmers’ choice of adaptation methods to climate change in the Nile Basin of Ethiopia. Global Environ Chang 19(2):248–255
Dirmeyer PA (2000) Using a Global Soil Wetness Dataset to Improve Seasonal Climate Simulation. J Climate 13(16):2900–2922
Ferretti MP, Pavone V (2009) What do civil society organisations expect from participation in science? Lessons from Germany and Spain on the issue of GMOs. Sci Public Policy 36(4):287–299
Fischer F (2000) Citizens, experts and the environment: the politics of local knowledge. Duke University Press, London
Fischer G, Shah M, et al (2005) Socio-economic and climate change impacts on agriculture: an integrated assessment, 1990–2080. Phil Trans R Soc B 360(1463):2067–2083
Fischer G, Velthuizen H, et al (2009) Potentially obtainable yields in the semi-arid tropics. Global Theme on Agroecosystems-Report (54)
Heng KL, Hsiao T, et al. (2009) Validating the FAO AquaCrop Model for Irrigated and Water Deficient Field Maize. Agronomy Journal 101(3):488–498
Huber-Sannwald E, Maestre FT et al (2006) Ecohydrological feedbacks and linkages associated with land degradation: a case study from Mexico. Hydrol Process 20(15):3395–3411
Indeje M, Semazzi FHM et al (2000) ENSO signals in East African rainfall seasons. Int J Climatol 20(1):19–46
IPCC (2001) Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis. In: Houghton JT, Ding Y, DJ et al. (eds) Contribution of Working Group I to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Irwin A (2001) Constructing the scientific citizen: science and democracy in the biosciences. Public Underst Sci 10(1):1–18
Jasanoff S (ed) (2004) States of knowledge: the co-production of science and social order. Routledge, London
Jones PD, Osborn TJ, Briffa KR (2001) The Evolution of Climate over the Last Millennium. Science, 292(5517):662–667
Kasperson RE, Renn O et al (1988) The social amplification of risk: a conceptual framework. Risk Anal 8(2):177–187
Kuhn TS (1986) The structure of scientific revolutions. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Lahsen M (2005) Seductive simulations? Uncertainty distribution around climate models. Soc Stud Sci 35:895
Lambert SJ, Boer GJ (2001) CMIP1 evaluation and intercomparison of coupled climate models. Clim Dyn 17(2):83–106
Le Treut H, Somerville R et al (2007) Historical overview of climate change. In: Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M et al (eds) Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge, United Kingdom
Leach M, Scoones I et al (eds) (2005) Science and citizens: globalization and the challenge of engagement. Zed Books, London
Longino HE (1990) Science as social knowledge. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Meehl GA, Boer GJ et al (2000) The coupled model intercomparison project (CMIP). Bull Am Meteorol Soc 81(2):313–318
Nachtergaele FO (1999). From the soil map of the world to the digital global soil and terrain database: 1960–2002. In: Sumner ME (ed) Handbook of Soil Science. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL
Nakicenovic N, Alcamo J, et al. (2000) Special Report on Emissions Scenarios, Working Group III, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK,
Nelson GC, Rosengrant MW, et al (2009) Climate change: impact on agriculture and costs of adaptation. Intl Food Policy Research Inst
Parry M (2004) Global impacts of climate change under the SRES scenarios. Glob Environ Chang 14(1):1
Parry ML, Rosenzweig C, et al. (2004) Effects of climate change on global food production under SRES emissions and socio-economic scenarios. Glob Environ Chang 14(1):53–67
Pawson R (2006) Evidence-based policy: a realist perspective. Sage Publications, London
Pidgeon N, Fischhoff B (2011) The role of social and decision sciences in communicating uncertain climate risks. Nat Clim Chang 1(1):35–41
Randall DA, Wood RA et al (2007) Cilmate models and their evaluation. In: Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M et al (eds) Climate change 2007: the physical science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge, United Kingdom
Reed MS (2008) Stakeholder participation for environmental management: a literature review. Biol Conserv 141(10):2417–2431
Renn O (1999) A model for an analytic-deliberative process in risk management. Environ Sci Technol 33(18):3049–3055
Renn O (2008) Risk governance: coping with uncertainty in a complex world. Earthscan, London
Renn O, Schweizer P-J (2009) Inclusive risk governance: concepts and application to environmental policy making. Environ Policy Gov 19(3):174–185
Renn O, Burns WJ et al (2010) The social amplification of risk: theoretical foundations and empirical applications. J Soc Issues 48(4):137–160
Robertson R, Nelson G et al (2012) Incorporating process based crop simulation models into global economic analyses. Am J Agric Econ 95(2):228–235
Sacks WJ, Deryng D, et al. (2010) Crop planting dates: an analysis of global patterns. Global Ecol Biogeogr 19(5):607–620
Sanchez PA, Ahamed S, et al (2009) Digital Soil Map of the World: Policy Forum. Science 325:680–681
Schmidt M, Torgersen H et al (2008) SYNBIOSAFE e-conference: online community discussion on the societal aspects of synthetic biology. Syst Synth Biol 2(1):7–17
Sellke P, Renn O (2010) Risk, society and environmental policy: risk governance in a complex world. In: Gross M, Heinrichs H (eds) Environmental sociology. Springer, Netherlands, pp 295–321
Shackley S, Young P et al (1998) Uncertainty, complexity and concepts of good science in climate change modelling: are GCMs the best tools? Clim Chang 38(2):159–205
Smith S (2000) Qualitative methods. In: Johnston R, Gregory D, Pratt G, Watts M (eds) The dictionary of human geography. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, pp 660–662
Stern PC, Fineberg H (eds) (1996) Understanding Risk: Informing Decisions in a Democratic Society. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
Stirling A (1999) The appraisal of sustainability: some problems and possible responses. Local Environ 4(2):111–135
Swart R, Bernstein L et al (2009) Agreeing to disagree: uncertainty management in assessing climate change, impacts and responses by the IPCC. Clim Chang 92(1):1–29
Tatsumi K, Yamashiki Y et al (2011) Estimation of potential changes in cereals production under climate change scenarios. Hydrol Process 25(17):2715–2725
Taylor KE, Stouffer RJ et al (2012) An overview of CMIP5 and the experiment design. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 93(4):485
Thornton PK, Jones PG et al (2009) Spatial variation of crop yield response to climate change in East Africa. Glob Environ Chang 19(1):54–65
Thornton PK, Jones PG et al (2010) Adapting to climate change: agricultural system and household impacts in East Africa. Agric Syst 103(2):73–82
Thornton PK, Jones PG, et al (2011) Agriculture and food systems in sub-Saharan Africa in a 4 C+ world. Phil. Trans. R. Soc A 369:117–136
Thornton PK, Saka AR, et al (1995) Application of a Maize Crop Simulation Model in the Central Region of Malawi. Exp Agr 31(2):213–226
Tingem M, Rivington M (2009) Adaptation for crop agriculture to climate in Cameroon: Turning on the heat. Mitig Adapt Strategy Glob Change 14:153–168
Tsouvalis J, Seymour S et al (2000) Exploring knowledge-cultures: precision farming, yield mapping, and the expert—farmer interface. Environ Plan A 32(5):909–924
Ummenhofer CC, Sen Gupta A et al (2009) Contributions of Indian Ocean sea surface temperatures to enhanced East African rainfall. J Clim 22(4):993–1013
Van Vuuren D, Stehfest E, et al. (2011) RCP2.6: exploring the possibility to keep temperature increase below 2°C. Climatic Change 109:95–116
Voinov A, Bousquet F (2010) Modelling with stakeholders. Environ Model Softw 25(11):1268–1281
Webster M (2003) Communicating climate change uncertainty to policy-makers and the public. Clim Chang 61(1):1–8
Weldon S (2004) “Public consent” or “scientific citizenship”? What counts as public participation in population based DNA collections? In: Tutton R, Corrigan O (eds) Socio-ethical issues in the collection and use of DNA. Routledge, London, pp 161–180
Whitfield S (2012) Evidence-based agricultural policy in Africa: critical reflection on an emergent discourse. Outlook Agric 41(4):249–256
Whitfield S, Reed M (2011) Participatory environmental assessment in drylands: introducing a new approach. J Arid Environ 77:1–10
Williams AP, Funk C (2011) A westward extension of the warm pool leads to a westward extension of the Walker circulation, drying eastern Africa. Clim Dyn 37(11):2417–2435
Wynne B (2006) Public engagement as a means of restoring public trust in science—hitting the notes, but missing the music? Public Health Genomics 9(3):211–220
Wynne B, Shackley S (1994) Environmental models: truth machines or social heuristics. Globe 21:6–8
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Whitfield, S. Uncertainty, ignorance and ambiguity in crop modelling for African agricultural adaptation. Climatic Change 120, 325–340 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-013-0795-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-013-0795-3